Sunday, August 11, 2013

Historical "versus" experimental science - a nice analogy

One of the favorite arguments of creationists is, at its root, "have you seen evolution happen"? Because nobody has seen the transformation from microbe to worm, from worm to fish, from fish to tetrapod, etc., happen in real time, there is supposedly no reason to believe it happened, despite the wealth of fossil, phylogenetic and other data supporting the conclusion.

More sophisticated creationists try to wrap this idea into slightly more reasonable sounding language. They make a distinction between experimental science and historical science, arguing that only the first is real science because its experiments can be reproduced at any time. Evolutionary biology, they say, is a historical undertaking and thus much more open to interpretation.

Now obviously this argumentation is completely idiotic anyway. We can infer things about the past, we can infer to the best explanation, and we can reproducibly test hypotheses. For what is perhaps the simplest example, every time a palaeontologist fails to find fossils of mammals before the first fossils of marine fish, they provide a little more support for evolution and against special creation because under the latter "theory" one would expect fossils of all lineages to co-occur together right from the earliest strata.

However, it is always best to have a pithy analogy in these situations. At least I strongly believe that a good mental picture is worth a thousand carefully weighted words (which is why I crafted this recent post, for example). And for this historical versus experimental silliness, for this "have you seen evolution happen" idiocy, a commenter at Jerry Coyne's WEIT website has just given the perfect analogy:
Becca Stareyes: I’ve also never seen an acorn grow into a giant oak tree, or a baby boy grow into an old man, but I would look pretty darn silly if I implied such things should be treated with skepticism. Because between my personal observations of human and tree growth and aging, and less-direct evidence, it becomes pretty damn obvious what’s going on.
This is definitely worth making a mental note of; the acorn example is beautiful in its simplicity, much easier to visualize and much better at showing the absurdity than an analogy using archaeology, for example. As a bonus, there is a reply poking fun at the infamous question "if humans evolved from monkeys, why are there still monkeys".
Rob: If acorns are trees why are there still acorns? Checkmate atheists!
That one could, of course, also be addressed by asking back "if you are descended from your mother, why does your mother still live?"

Friday, August 9, 2013

Tokogenetic relationships

During a discussion about species, a visiting colleague has argued that I am misusing the word "tokogenetic" (see here, here and basically everywhere I discuss phylogenetic systematics). Apparently the way Hennig originally intended the concept of a tokogenetic relationship to be used was not as a synonym for "net-like" but instead to describe the ancestor-descendant relationship, as from mother to daughter across generations.

If that is so, I will from now on try to avoid making that mistake. That being said, my previous misuse, both on this blog and in research papers, does not appear all too problematic because nearly everybody else seems to use the term in the same way, as a Google search easily demonstrates.

The important point, however, is that this insight does not change anything that matters: Regardless of whether they can or cannot be called tokogenetic in the original sense of the word, networks, or net-like structures, definitely do not contain monophyly or paraphyly. Only tree-like, phylogenetic structures can contain monophyly or paraphyly.

This is why anybody arguing that reticulation makes it necessary to accept paraphyletic taxa only demonstrates their own conceptual confusion. As do those arguing that the members of the same sexually reproducing species form a monophyletic group or clade, of course.

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Botany picture #93: Mandragora officinarum


Mandragora officinarum (Solanaceae), Botanic Garden of Zürich, 2009. The mandrake is of course well known from legend and, lately, Harry Potter. The root was believed to possess magical properties but the plant would utter a deadly scream when harvested. Supposedly some people would bind dogs to the plant and then walk off, hoping that only the dog would die when the plant screamed and one could afterwards pick up the root.

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Consciousness raiser: Trade-offs

Some recent discussions I was involved in appeared to suffer from two circumstances: First, that many participants were talking past each other because they were not quite agreed on what the controversy was actually about, and, two, a lack of appreciation of certain aspects of reality on one side of the discussion. Aspects of reality, admittedly, that we humans are very likely to get wrong. So this post is once more mostly exploring the issue for my own benefit and perhaps for later reference if ever needed.

Today, let us consider the concept of trade-offs. When discussing the potential for future technological innovations with the kind of people one might classify as singularitarians, transhumanists, cornucopians or simply technology-optimists, one cannot help but become puzzled at their often very simplistic view of technological feasibility and progress. Many of them seem to believe that the history of engineering can be summarized as undertakings that had previously been impossible gradually becoming possible once the awesome power of the human mind is properly applied to them, and that this trend will merrily continue into the future.

That is, of course, a very one-sided perception. Yes, there have been many cases where doubters were proved spectacularly wrong, for example when it was stated that trains could not go faster than a couple tens of kilometers per hour without killing the passengers. However, Jules Verne's cannon shooting astronauts into orbit really has to remain fiction for just that reason: there is no way of accelerating a projectile (as opposed to a rocket) fast enough to reach escape velocity without killing the astronauts. There simply isn't, and that is how it will remain regardless of how much science and engineering progress.

The same is true of perpetua mobiles, for example. Some things are ruled out by the physical realities of our universe, and the same is very likely to be true for many other pipe dreams futurists are coming up with. It may well be that there is no way of traveling to another star system and surviving the journey, of running a stable fusion reaction at a scale smaller than a star, or of uploading a mind into a computer. (Then again, I am only certain about the last of these.)

But beyond plain "this violates the laws of physics" level of impossibility, one of the really under-appreciated reasons that something might turn out to be impossible are trade-offs. What does that mean? It is simply the observation that to achieve some benefit A you often have to accept some correlated downside B.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Botany picture #92: Cladia retipora


We have a lichenologist visiting our institute this week, and so I thought I could upload a picture of the only Australian lichen whose name I know at the moment. And isn't it stunning? Cladia retipora (Cladoniaceae), Tasmania, 2012. Its common name is 'coral lichen'.

Friday, August 2, 2013

Botany picture #91: Scrophularia nodosa


Scrophularia nodosa (Scrophulariaceae), Botanic Garden of Halle, Germany, 2008. These plants are mostly wasp-pollinated, a rather rare pollination syndrome with often small, easily accessible, dull coloured flowers.

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Botany picture #90: Ornamental cherry tree


Winter, if you can call it that, is odd here in Canberra. The locals like to complain how cold it is but for a German it is really only like three or four months of late autumn; there is no snow and ice, and unless there is severe fog it always warms up nicely during the day. (Perhaps it would help if Australians would dress for the weather, but no! They seem to insist that one should be able to walk around in flip flops and shorts even at 5°C because this is Australia goddammit.)

The flora at least perceives the non-winter precisely as I do. The last leaves of introduced trees in the city parks have hardly fallen and you can already see spring flowering coming into full swing. It is now end of July/beginning of August, translating into end of January/beginning of February in a northern hemisphere winter, which would in Germany generally be followed by a full month of more deep frosty winter, with spring flowers then usually only really starting to come out in March. Yet here the cherries are already blooming and, as you can see in today's botany picture taken last Saturday, even quite close to finishing (note the brown colour of most stamens). As for native plants, the wattles (Acacia) are also beginning to bloom.

Admittedly, this July is also exceptionally warm after a summer that was so ridiculously hot that new colours had to be added to weather maps.